i-banner-1

We Buy Gold and Diamonds

i-banner-1

We Buy Gold and Diamonds

We purchase precious metals, diamonds, coins, estate jewelry, and even dental gold. Let us evaluate your items while you wait; get paid on the spot, or use the value toward a new purchase and get 20% more for your trade!

i-banner-2

Referral & Rewards Program

i-banner-2

Referral & Rewards Program

Opt-in to our rewards program to earn real dollar rewards with every jewelry purchase. Spend them on your next purchase or save them up- they are YOUR dollars to spend when you’re ready. Earn bonus rewards when you refer a friend and they purchase with us! See a sales associate for details.

i-banner-3

Financing Options

i-banner-3

Financing Options

Subject to Approved Credit


Click here to learn more.

i-banner-4

Always Complimentary

i-banner-4

Always Complimentary

  • Jewelry cleaning using ultrasonic cleaner and high-pressure steam

  • First sizing with any ring purchase

  • Gift wrapping in our signature paper

  • Examination and testing for jewelry authenticity

  • First three rhodium platings on engagement rings purchased here with nominal fees thereafter

  • Coffee or Tea, Cookies & RingPops!

i-banner-5

Hassle-Free Exchanges

i-banner-5

Hassle-Free Exchanges

We know that jewelry is one of the most personal gifts you can give; we also know that sometimes your taste doesn’t match that of your partner’s. If for any reason the recipient doesn’t absolutely love the gift you’ve chosen, he or she is able to exchange the item(s) for full credit toward anything else in the store, even if it means having something customized to taste.

i-banner-6

Custom Jewelry Design

i-banner-6

Custom Jewelry Design

Michael Agnello is an award winning jewelry designer and would love to customize a piece just for you. Whether re-working an inherited piece of jewelry, creating a wedding band to compliment an existing engagement ring, or commissioning Michael to create a one-of-a-kind treasure, let Michael Agnello Jewelers bring your idea to life.

i-banner-7

Trade In, Trade Up

i-banner-7

Trade In, Trade Up

Michael Agnello Jewelers is pleased to offer a diamond upgrade program, ensuring that at any time you can decide to make your ring even more beautiful with a diamond of greater value.

This allows you to purchase a diamond at your budget now and whenever you are ready, you can simply return and upgrade to a bigger or higher quality diamond.

On diamonds purchased from Michael Agnello Jewelers, you will be given full credit for the value of the diamond which then can be used toward the purchase of any other diamond of greater value of your choosing. If the value of your original diamond has increased since the time of purchase, you will receive the increase in value as well, along with a discount on the new diamond. If your original diamond was not purchased from Michael Agnello Jewelers, we will still trade your diamond!

Valentine's Day Gift Tips to Make Your Sweetheart Smile

Want to bring a smile to her lips this holiday? Check out Michael Agnello’s top Valentine’s Day gift tips.

What’s the perfect Valentine’s Day gift for her? The truth is, there is no one answer to this question. After all, women are individuals, and their jewelry preferences vary based on a number of factors.

Luckily, we have a step by step guide to help you come up with a thoughtful gift that she will cherish and truly enjoy. All you have to do is take a few moments to consider her personality and style and then check out the Valentine’s Day gift tips below from the team at Michael Agnello Jewelers.

How to Choose the Right Gift for Your Gal

Think of the words that best describe the love of your life. Is she thoughtful and dreamy, or wild and unpredictable, or organized and efficient? Does she like bold clothing that showcases her vibrant personality, or does she prefer classic, understated outfits that never go out of fashion?

The goal is to start thinking about your sweetheart’s character and her favorite ways to express herself and then how these factors impact her style choices. Once you’ve come up with some terms to describe the No. 1 woman in your life, you can start to think about the type of gift she’d prefer.

Meaningful Pieces

Has this year held particular challenges for the love of your life? If so, you might want to choose a piece of jewelry that’s more meaningful in honor of Valentine's Day.

Consider the type of jewelry she wears regularly when making your selection. For example, if her taste tends toward the classic, you might opt for an eternity band to add to her existing wedding set. Featuring a circle of small diamonds, these bands symbolize a couple’s lasting love. On the other hand, if you want a choice that’s equally elegant but less traditional, these pearl and gold drop earrings are guaranteed to please.

Of course, if you and your sweetie aren’t yet married, Valentine’s Day is the perfect time to pop the question with a stunning engagement ring!

Trendy Designs

Some women love keeping up with the latest trends. If style is a way of life for your sweetheart, you might want to opt for a Valentine’s Day jewelry gift that’s as fresh as it is fashionable. Simple yet en vogue, stud earrings can be easily customized using her favorite metals and gems, especially colored gems in her birthstone or favorite color. We’re big fans of these Simon G Mosaic earrings with a pave setting for white gold lovers.

Then again, if the love of your life tends toward warmer colors, you may want to choose this Frederic Sage necklace with a trendy circle pendant. The diamonds accenting this rose gold piece add a little extra elegance.

Make Michael Agnello Your Source for Valentine’s Day Jewelry

Michael Agnello Jewelers is proud to be an award-winning small business that serves shoppers in Connecticut and beyond. Whether you’re searching for a Valentine’s Day gift or the perfect bridal jewelry, our team has the taste and experience to help you choose something extraordinary. For help finding the perfect piece of jewelry, stop by today or search our designer collections online

Track Order

Returning Customers

Sign in to your account to track orders and view your order history.

Quick Track

Don't have an account? Enter your order number and email address below to track your order.